国产av日韩一区二区三区精品,成人性爱视频在线观看,国产,欧美,日韩,一区,www.成色av久久成人,2222eeee成人天堂

Home Web Front-end CSS Tutorial Is CSS a Programming Language?

Is CSS a Programming Language?

Mar 24, 2025 am 10:16 AM

Is CSS a Programming Language?

I have a real distaste for this question. It might seem like a fun question to dig into on the surface, but the way it enters public discourse rarely seems to be in good faith. There are ulterior motives at play involving respect, protective emotions, and desires to break or maintain the status quo.

If someone can somehow prove that CSS isn’t a programming language (this is such a gray area that if that was your goal, it wouldn’t be terribly hard to do) then they get to keep on feeling superior in their “real” programming skills and rationalize the fact that they are (likely) paid more than a front-of-the-front-ender specializing in CSS. This is maintaining the status quo.

The reverse can also be true. If you can prove that CSS is a programming language, perhaps you can shift your own company or the industry at large toward equal respect and pay toward front-of-the-front-end developers. This is breaking the status quo.

Let’s say we could all agree on a boolean true or false on if CSS is a programming language. What now? If true, is pay normalized among all web workers? If false, do CSS specialists deserve pay cuts? If true, does everyone start respecting each other in a way they don’t now? If false, do CSS people have to eat lunch in the boiler room? I have doubts that anything will change; hence my distaste for the discussion at all.

Whatever the facts, it’s unlikely most people are going to accept even the possibility that CSS is a programming language. I mean, programs execute, don’t they? Nobody doubts that JavaScript is a programming language, because it executes. You write code and then execute that code. Perhaps you open a terminal window and write:

> node my-program.js

Sure as eggs is eggs, that program will execute. You can make “Hello, World!” print to the terminal with console.log("Hello, World!");.

CSS can’t do that! Um, well, unless you write body::after { content: "Hello, World!"; } in style.css file and open a web page that loads that CSS file. So CSS does execute, in its own special way. It’s a domain-specific language (DSL) rather than a general-purpose language (GPL). In that browser context, the way CSS is told to run (, usually) isn’t even that different from how JavaScript is told to run (<script>, usually).</script>

If you’re looking for comparisons for CSS syntax to programming concepts, I think you’ll find them. What is a selector if not a type of if statement that runs a loop over matches? What is calc() if not a direct implementation of math? What is a group of media queries if not a switch? What is a custom property if not a place to store state? What is :checked if not boolean? Eric recently made the point that CSS is typed, and earlier, that CSS is chock full of functions.

For better or worse, having an answer to whether or not CSS is a programming language affects people. One college professor had made a point of telling students that CSS is not Turing complete, but is now re-considering that position upon learning that it is. Whatever the intention there, I think the industry is affected by what computer science professors tell computer science students year after year.

Lara Schenck has dug into the Turing-complete angle. If you’re trying to settle this, Turing completeness is a good proxy. It turns out that CSS basically is Turing complete (by settling the cellular automaton angle of Rule 110), just not entirely by itself. It involves a somewhat complex use of selectors and :checked (surprise, surprise). Lara makes an astute point:

Alone, CSS isnotTuring complete. CSS plus HTML plus user input is Turing complete!

Still, say you don’t buy it. You get it and even concede, OK fine, CSS is essentially Turing complete, but it just doesn’t feel like CSS (or HTML for that matter) is a programming language to you. It’s too declarative. Too application-specific. Whatever it is, I honestly don’t blame you. What I hope is that whatever conclusion you come to, the answer doesn’t affect things that really matter1, like pay and respect.

Respect is in order, no matter what any of us come to for an answer. I don’t consider CSS a programming language, but it doesn’t mean I think it’s trivial or that my specialist co-workers are any less valuable than my Python specialist co-workers. Wouldn’t that be nice? I think there is an interesting distinction between declarative markup languages and other types of languages, but they are all code. Oh stop it, you know how thoughtful answers make me blush.

I’d like to see a lot more nuanced, respectful, and agenda-less comments like that when these discussions happen.

  1. Just like “website” vs “web app.” Whether or not you think there is a distinction, I would hope people aren’t making decisions that affect users based on what taxonomical bucket you think your thing goes in. ?

The above is the detailed content of Is CSS a Programming Language?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Statement of this Website
The content of this article is voluntarily contributed by netizens, and the copyright belongs to the original author. This site does not assume corresponding legal responsibility. If you find any content suspected of plagiarism or infringement, please contact admin@php.cn

Hot AI Tools

Undress AI Tool

Undress AI Tool

Undress images for free

Undresser.AI Undress

Undresser.AI Undress

AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover

AI Clothes Remover

Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Clothoff.io

Clothoff.io

AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap

Video Face Swap

Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1

Notepad++7.3.1

Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version

SublimeText3 Chinese version

Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Zend Studio 13.0.1

Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6

Dreamweaver CS6

Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version

SublimeText3 Mac version

God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

How can I include CSS only on some pages? How can I include CSS only on some pages? Jun 11, 2025 am 12:01 AM

There are three ways to selectively include CSS on a specific page: 1. Inline CSS, suitable for pages that are not frequently accessed or require unique styles; 2. Load external CSS files using JavaScript conditions, suitable for situations where flexibility is required; 3. Containment on the server side, suitable for scenarios using server-side languages. This approach can optimize website performance and maintainability, but requires balance of modularity and performance.

What is 'render-blocking CSS'? What is 'render-blocking CSS'? Jun 24, 2025 am 12:42 AM

CSS blocks page rendering because browsers view inline and external CSS as key resources by default, especially with imported stylesheets, header large amounts of inline CSS, and unoptimized media query styles. 1. Extract critical CSS and embed it into HTML; 2. Delay loading non-critical CSS through JavaScript; 3. Use media attributes to optimize loading such as print styles; 4. Compress and merge CSS to reduce requests. It is recommended to use tools to extract key CSS, combine rel="preload" asynchronous loading, and use media delayed loading reasonably to avoid excessive splitting and complex script control.

How to use Lotties in Figma How to use Lotties in Figma Jun 14, 2025 am 10:17 AM

In the following tutorial, I will show you how to create Lottie animations in Figma. We'll use two colorful designs to exmplify how you can animate in Figma, and then I'll show you how to go from Figma to Lottie animations. All you need is a free Fig

Breaking Boundaries: Building a Tangram Puzzle With (S)CSS Breaking Boundaries: Building a Tangram Puzzle With (S)CSS Jun 13, 2025 am 11:33 AM

We put it to the test and it turns out Sass can replace JavaScript, at least when it comes to low-level logic and puzzle behavior. With nothing but maps, mixins, functions, and a whole lot of math, we managed to bring our Tangram puzzle to life, no J

External vs. Internal CSS: What's the Best Approach? External vs. Internal CSS: What's the Best Approach? Jun 20, 2025 am 12:45 AM

ThebestapproachforCSSdependsontheproject'sspecificneeds.Forlargerprojects,externalCSSisbetterduetomaintainabilityandreusability;forsmallerprojectsorsingle-pageapplications,internalCSSmightbemoresuitable.It'scrucialtobalanceprojectsize,performanceneed

Does my CSS must be on lower case? Does my CSS must be on lower case? Jun 19, 2025 am 12:29 AM

No,CSSdoesnothavetobeinlowercase.However,usinglowercaseisrecommendedfor:1)Consistencyandreadability,2)Avoidingerrorsinrelatedtechnologies,3)Potentialperformancebenefits,and4)Improvedcollaborationwithinteams.

CSS Counters: A Step-by-Step Tutorial with Examples CSS Counters: A Step-by-Step Tutorial with Examples Jun 12, 2025 am 10:31 AM

CSSCounters is a tool for creating automatic numbers. 1. Basic usage: define and operate counters through counter-reset and counter-increment, such as "SectionX." before h2. 2. Advanced usage: Use nested counters to create complex numbers, such as chapter and section numbers. 3. Notes: Ensure the counter is reset correctly, optimize performance, and simplify counter logic. 4. Best practice: clear naming, define counters in CSS, and use counter-increment and counter-reset reasonably.

CSS Case Sensitivity: Understanding What Matters CSS Case Sensitivity: Understanding What Matters Jun 20, 2025 am 12:09 AM

CSSismostlycase-insensitive,butURLsandfontfamilynamesarecase-sensitive.1)Propertiesandvalueslikecolor:red;arenotcase-sensitive.2)URLsmustmatchtheserver'scase,e.g.,/images/Logo.png.3)Fontfamilynameslike'OpenSans'mustbeexact.

See all articles