Let's talk about specific design systems. While the underlying concept benefits nearly any website, the reality is more nuanced.
Design systems are currently generating significant buzz. Recently, a new design system's public release prompted a flurry of messages urging me to check it out. My initial reaction? "Looks good." But that's like glancing at a new car's exterior – a superficial assessment. True understanding requires extensive use, building multiple projects with it to truly evaluate its strengths and weaknesses.
This raises crucial questions: Is this design system suitable for my projects? Who is the intended audience?
The Ubiquitous Accordion
Many, though not all, design systems include accordions. This isn't coincidental; it highlights a key point.
Bootstrap: A Familiar Benchmark
Bootstrap's widespread adoption and understanding provide a valuable comparison. Its CSS and HTML components are readily integrated, offering a straightforward development experience.
Whether Bootstrap is strictly a "design system" or a "pattern library" is debatable. However, the interchangeable use of these terms underscores the existing confusion.
Developers choose Bootstrap for several reasons:
- Accelerated development.
- High-quality components, beneficial for developers with less HTML/CSS expertise.
- Robust accessibility features.
- [Insert your reason here]
These benefits, while appealing, are becoming standard expectations for any modern design system, not unique to Bootstrap.
Exploring Alternatives to Bootstrap
Many developers seek alternatives to Bootstrap. Reasons include:
- Project requirements (e.g., React integration).
- Difficulty customizing Bootstrap.
- Aesthetic preferences.
- Simple boredom.
The motivations for choosing or rejecting Bootstrap are numerous.
Selecting a Design System: Beyond the Accordion
Choosing a design system requires careful consideration. Licensing is a critical factor. Salesforce's Lightning Design System, often cited as a leader, is open-source licensed (BSD Clause-3, with Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 for fonts and icons). This license clarifies its intended use: primarily for Salesforce and its associated development teams. While publicly available, it's not a general-purpose solution for all web developers.
Why is it public? Salesforce's scale necessitates accessibility for both internal and external teams. Public availability facilitates collaboration and broadens its impact.
The discussion around open-source design systems and their specific use cases remains ongoing. Is "open source" the appropriate term, or is "source available" more accurate given the context-specific nature of design systems?
IBM's Carbon Design System, another open-source option, explicitly states its target audience: IBM designers and developers working on IBM products. While usable by others, its primary focus remains internal.
Company-Specific Focus
Company-created design systems inherently serve the company's needs first. Open-source licensing doesn't negate this primary focus. The same principle applies to government-developed systems, such as the U.S. Web Design System, which prioritizes government websites.
The U.S. Web Design System, largely public domain, is a valuable resource, but its design prioritizes government needs, not individual developers. Its open-source nature facilitates community contributions, impacting websites crucial to public life.
The Spectrum of Customizability
Design systems offer varying degrees of customizability:
- Zero Customizability: Enforcing strict consistency.
- Pre-Selected Variations: Offering limited customization options (e.g., color variations).
- BYO Theme: Providing a flexible framework for extensive customization.
Shopify's Polaris design system, while open-source, prioritizes internal consistency over extensive customization, unlike Bootstrap.
Google's Material Design, initially for internal use, is now actively promoted for external use. While initially enforcing a Google aesthetic, it's becoming more customizable, allowing for branding integration. Companies like Lyft, Zappos, and NPR demonstrate successful customization.
The messaging surrounding Material Design highlights the complexities of open-source design systems. It's simultaneously for Google and for anyone else who wants to use it, a feat enabled by Google's resources and brand recognition.
Design systems are not commodities; choosing one based solely on aesthetics is insufficient. Licensing, intended audience, and customizability must be carefully considered.
My advice to creators of public design systems: Clearly define your target audience and permitted usage. The interpretation of target audience messaging varies widely, underscoring the need for clear communication.
The above is the detailed content of Who Are Design Systems For?. For more information, please follow other related articles on the PHP Chinese website!

Hot AI Tools

Undress AI Tool
Undress images for free

Undresser.AI Undress
AI-powered app for creating realistic nude photos

AI Clothes Remover
Online AI tool for removing clothes from photos.

Clothoff.io
AI clothes remover

Video Face Swap
Swap faces in any video effortlessly with our completely free AI face swap tool!

Hot Article

Hot Tools

Notepad++7.3.1
Easy-to-use and free code editor

SublimeText3 Chinese version
Chinese version, very easy to use

Zend Studio 13.0.1
Powerful PHP integrated development environment

Dreamweaver CS6
Visual web development tools

SublimeText3 Mac version
God-level code editing software (SublimeText3)

Hot Topics

There are three ways to selectively include CSS on a specific page: 1. Inline CSS, suitable for pages that are not frequently accessed or require unique styles; 2. Load external CSS files using JavaScript conditions, suitable for situations where flexibility is required; 3. Containment on the server side, suitable for scenarios using server-side languages. This approach can optimize website performance and maintainability, but requires balance of modularity and performance.

CSS blocks page rendering because browsers view inline and external CSS as key resources by default, especially with imported stylesheets, header large amounts of inline CSS, and unoptimized media query styles. 1. Extract critical CSS and embed it into HTML; 2. Delay loading non-critical CSS through JavaScript; 3. Use media attributes to optimize loading such as print styles; 4. Compress and merge CSS to reduce requests. It is recommended to use tools to extract key CSS, combine rel="preload" asynchronous loading, and use media delayed loading reasonably to avoid excessive splitting and complex script control.

In the following tutorial, I will show you how to create Lottie animations in Figma. We'll use two colorful designs to exmplify how you can animate in Figma, and then I'll show you how to go from Figma to Lottie animations. All you need is a free Fig

We put it to the test and it turns out Sass can replace JavaScript, at least when it comes to low-level logic and puzzle behavior. With nothing but maps, mixins, functions, and a whole lot of math, we managed to bring our Tangram puzzle to life, no J

ThebestapproachforCSSdependsontheproject'sspecificneeds.Forlargerprojects,externalCSSisbetterduetomaintainabilityandreusability;forsmallerprojectsorsingle-pageapplications,internalCSSmightbemoresuitable.It'scrucialtobalanceprojectsize,performanceneed

No,CSSdoesnothavetobeinlowercase.However,usinglowercaseisrecommendedfor:1)Consistencyandreadability,2)Avoidingerrorsinrelatedtechnologies,3)Potentialperformancebenefits,and4)Improvedcollaborationwithinteams.

CSSCounters is a tool for creating automatic numbers. 1. Basic usage: define and operate counters through counter-reset and counter-increment, such as "SectionX." before h2. 2. Advanced usage: Use nested counters to create complex numbers, such as chapter and section numbers. 3. Notes: Ensure the counter is reset correctly, optimize performance, and simplify counter logic. 4. Best practice: clear naming, define counters in CSS, and use counter-increment and counter-reset reasonably.

CSSismostlycase-insensitive,butURLsandfontfamilynamesarecase-sensitive.1)Propertiesandvalueslikecolor:red;arenotcase-sensitive.2)URLsmustmatchtheserver'scase,e.g.,/images/Logo.png.3)Fontfamilynameslike'OpenSans'mustbeexact.
